I have a question—if a
rooster attacks a livestock guardian dog, who's at fault?
I wasn't entirely sure myself
when I walked into the chicken yard yesterday morning and
discovered what looked suspiciously like a crime scene. Standing in
the middle of the yard was Gus Gus, my 130-pound livestock guardian
dog. At his feet lay Mike Crowe, my Light Brahma rooster, looking
like he'd just lost an argument with a freight train. Gus was
standing over him while Mike remained perfectly motionless. Since Gus
has lived peacefully with the flock for years, I couldn't imagine
what had happened.
I immediately scolded Gus. He lowered his head and retreated
toward the tent shelter with all the confidence of a teenager who has
just been caught sneaking in after curfew. I picked up Mike and
carried him to the coop, where he remained limp and unresponsive for
several minutes. Then one eye opened. A few minutes later he
staggered to his feet, rearranged his ruffled feathers with an
indignant shake, and looked around to make sure none of the hens were
watching. Then he disappeared into the chick pen to recover what
little dignity remained. Meanwhile, Gus watched the entire
performance from the shelter.
When I scolded him a second time, Gus apparently decided the
shelter wasn't far enough away. He headed for the far side of the
pasture and disappeared into the trees. That struck me as odd. A dog
that intentionally decides to attack chickens usually doesn't look
guilty afterward. Gus looked guilty enough to plead for a reduced
sentence.
 |
| Mike Crowe |
As he slunk away, I called after him.
"Gus! What did you do?"
He turned and gave me a look that said,
"But Mom, he started it!"
As I stood there trying to make sense of the situation, I noticed
Gus's breakfast still lying untouched inside the shelter. Earlier
that morning I had given him a large frozen meaty bone. Since he
hadn't eaten it, I decided to pick it up and put it back in the
freezer for another day. As I bent down to retrieve it, I discovered
something I hadn't noticed before.
A dead hen lay beneath a nearby table.
That was when the mystery began to unravel.
My best guess is that Gus had been lying beside his prized bone
trying to decide whether to eat it immediately or bury it for later.
Dogs seem convinced that food improves with age. One of the hens
apparently noticed the unattended treasure and decided to
investigate. Chickens are not burdened by concepts such as ownership,
personal space, or common sense. If a chicken sees food, she assumes
it belongs to her. If another chicken sees it first, she assumes it
belongs to her anyway.
I suspect the hen wandered over and pecked at the bone. Gus
probably responded with the canine equivalent of, "Excuse me,
but that's mine." Unfortunately, chickens are surprisingly
fragile creatures. What would have been a harmless warning to another
dog would have had much more serious consequences for a hen. I don't
believe Gus intended to kill her. In all the years he has lived with
the flock, he has never shown aggression toward any of the chickens.
I suspect it was simply an unfortunate accident.
The hen almost certainly voiced her opinion about the situation at
maximum volume. Anyone who keeps chickens knows there is a difference
between ordinary chicken chatter and a full-scale emergency
broadcast. A hen in distress can produce a sound capable of bringing
every chicken within hearing distance running to see what's going on.
More importantly, it can bring a rooster.
Somewhere in the yard, Mike Crowe undoubtedly heard the commotion
and came charging toward the scene. Now, I've been on the receiving
end of Mike's temper before. Mike does not believe in backing down.
Nor does he believe in carefully evaluating the odds. Mike believes
that if one of his hens is in trouble, it is his responsibility to
charge directly into the situation and sort out the details later.
When he arrived and found a hen down with Gus standing nearby,
Mike didn't bother collecting evidence or interviewing witnesses. He
took one look at the scene, appointed himself judge and jury, and
transformed into Inigo Montoya.
"You killed my hen. Prepare to die."
What followed was likely less of a fight and more of a sustained
military campaign. Mike attacked. Gus backed away. Mike attacked
again. Gus backed away farther. Mike attacked again because the
previous attacks had not adequately expressed his opinion.
Roosters are not known for diplomacy. They tend to approach
conflict with the subtlety of a chainsaw.
At some point Gus probably stopped viewing Mike as one of his
chickens and started viewing him as a hostile feathered predator that
refused to leave him alone. Livestock guardian instincts eventually
took over, bringing us to the scene I discovered: one guilty dog, one
battered rooster, and a mystery waiting to be solved.
What still makes me laugh is that when I found them, Mike wasn't
fighting anymore. He was lying perfectly still beneath Gus.
Apparently, after discovering that attacking a 130-pound livestock
guardian dog was not producing the desired results, he had switched
to Plan B and decided to play dead. To his credit, the strategy
worked. By the time I arrived, Gus was simply standing over him
looking confused while Mike was putting on an Academy Award-worthy
performance.
The more I thought about it, the more I began to suspect that
Gus's defense may have contained at least a grain of truth. From his
perspective, he had been minding his own business, guarding his
breakfast, when a hen interfered, a rooster declared war, and somehow
he ended up being the one in trouble.
Of course, the dead hen under the table weakened his argument
considerably.
In the end, the scorecard was mixed. The hen was beyond caring
about the outcome. Mike lost several feathers and a considerable
amount of dignity. Gus lost his good standing with management and
received a stern lecture about proper workplace conduct. I, however,
gained valuable information.
From now on, Gus gets to finish breakfast before the chickens are
released from the coop.
The funny thing is that I doubt either of the boys learned
anything. Gus will still guard his food. Mike will still defend his
hens. The only creature involved with enough sense to change future
behavior was me.
Still, you have to admire Mike. A ten-pound rooster willingly
attacked a 130-pound livestock guardian dog in defense of one of his
hens. That's either courage or insanity. With Mike, it's usually
both.
So back to the original question—whose fault was it? Gus? Mike?
Or the idiot who handed out the bone?
Enjoyed this tale from the barnyard?
Don’t miss the next round of critter chaos — to get new stories by email,
just send a note to sandydavis@aol.com
or follow on Facebook.
๐ If you liked this story, please click one of the small share buttons below instead of copy-paste—it helps folks find their way back here for more tales from the farm.๐
©2026 Sandy Davis | American Way Farm